The letter, titled "WHY I HATE AMERICA", which follows my below commentary contains a message which every American should read. It was written by a disgusted, but not unique, American.

 

 

 

Richard's Commentary

 

The author of the below letter, "Why I Hate America", Lee Roskin, chose a strong word 'hate'. It is a forthright and honest admission, though it may not be the best word - neither for putting across his truly stand-up (morally courageous) message, nor for protecting his own balanced sensibilities, long-term. There is no use hating 'America' for the negative and inhumane history he objectively recounts, for that only serves to emotionalize the subject for some readers while being of little service to the victims of America's many aggressions.

 

That caveat aside, most objective and historically honest readers reflecting on his comments may not necessary reach exactly the same strong conclusion but they would either be irrational or moral cowards if they tried to deny his accuracy in narrating the uniquely negative worldwide record of aggression and exploitation America has accumulated.

 

He is 100% correct indicating references to America's mercenary, illegal, inhumane and often murderous record dealing with all peoples from racial minorities, most Third World countries, most weaker countries (we love to bully anyone with nerve enough to disagree), and virtually all peoples America has classified as 'inferior' over its long history of exploiting the "other". Ours is a most nasty record, right in the same traditions of Spain and UK.

 

We started with the Native 'Indian' tribes millions of whom we murdered, robbed and raped for over 300 years, while for another 300 years we enslaved, debased and murdered every Black brought in chains to our Arcadia; then continued with unwarranted aggressions against the Spanish, Seminols and Blacks in greater Florida, the Mexicans (stealing almost half of their country); next we threatened Japan with a Naval incendiary bombardment of civilian cities if they refused to open to trade; then pushed southern 'Rebels in the bloodiest war in US history'; next was stealing Hawaii and murdering 200,000 Filipinos and a lesser amount of Cubans; then for the next 100 years we continued...... INTO OVER THIRTY COUNTRIES TO WHICH AMERICA HAS UNILATERALLY SENT ITS TROOPERS EXPRESSLY FOR COMMERCIAL PROFITEERING.

 

The most recent case being the wars we started in Indochina (contravening FDR's 1943 written policy), which wound up killing over 6,000,000 Indochinese from 9/1945 to the late 1980s when the CIA finally stopped its Black Operations over there.

 

This is OUR true HISTORY, not just his or my opinion. So any American not accepting his terse accounting is simply not aware of two devastating realities: 1) the true history of our violent country, and 2) the inordinately high number of foreigners who feel either exactly as Roskin does or close enough to reach similar judgements.

 

The worst and saddest part of this story is that until enough of our fellow citizens wake up to this reality - - wake up from their propaganda induced dream, entitled "America is the Best" - - the inhumanity perpetrated by THEIR corporate controlled government, IN THEIR NAME, will get worse and worse. Until the next blowback, perhaps a far more tragic revenge than the WTC attacks. No matter how many and sophisticated our weapons, no matter how many people we kill and/or intimidate, mankind has a long history of achieving bloody revenge against bloody bullies.

 

richard manning

 

 

NB: CONCERNING PATRIOTISM - please see my short essay, "Patriotism" here on this site.

...which tells a bit about what happened to one honestly John Wayne Jesus Christ American who, while in Vietnam, started to learn America's true history in Indochina; and, afterwards, learned about similar aggressions by his country throughout much of the world.

 

 

 

Why I Hate America

 by Lee Roskin

 

Iıve been asking myself why I hate America, why the anger rises up when I hear words about Americaıs triumph over terrorism. Why am I so perverse when America is doing so much good and is being successful in making the world a better place? When the news media and solemn politicians say that we must stand united, bless America and support itıs wars, why do I feel just the opposite. Why do I feel unpatriotic, cynical and disgusted with this country. Perhaps there is something to be learned here. Perhaps, if I, as a USA citizen, born, raised and educated here, prospered here, can discern this antipathy, it might give some indication why much of the rest of the world feels that way and that Pres. Bush and the American public seem to have no idea about.

 

First of all, what is America? I am not referring to the geographical entity of the USA which is quite beautiful outside the ruined cities, debased countryside and vast stretches of wasteland. There is much beauty here in the forests, shores, mountains, lakes and rivers, plains -- the physical nature of America is not what I am talking about. I am not talking about 'the American people' directly which obviously at 280,000,000 is quite diverse and multifaceted. I am also not talking directly about 'what America stands for' as far as history, principles and values which are variable and diverse from the most admirable to the most loathsome. However, I am speaking about the American people and what America stands for indirectly in that I am speaking about the American attitude. If one can believe the mass media, civic and religious leaders and politicians, the over riding attitude that Americans have about America is that it is the best place in the world, with superior citizens, leadership and morality.

 

In and of itself, this arrogance, bragging and smugness would not seem so hateful except for two reasons: it is based on falsehood and deception and it is based on the deprivation and diminution of people in places that are not the USA. Arrogance and bragging are not in themselves major hateful qualities but when they are coupled with cruelty, hypocrisy, cheating and savagery, they become almost unbearable. It is the glaring contradiction of the 'greatness of America' with the depredations and barbarity of America that leads one into despising the country in which one was born. Perhaps this is what many foreigners see -- the lie, the ugly lie that is so infuriating. Perhaps they see the democracy that elects venal fools, the media that controls the citizens minds, the arrogance of the rich, the degradation of the poor, the racial hatred, the religious intolerance, the debased environment -- all the wonderful and great things that God has bestowed upon his favorite people.

 

 

Perhaps many people in the world see, as I do, the evil hand of America that allows the cruelest, most repressive of regimes to survive if it serves the purposes of America while destroying others what do not benefit America -- look to the recent history of Central and South America, Asia or Africa, if you do not know what I am referring to because the catalog of hideous American intervention is very long.

 

And what is one to think of the slaughter of innocent civilians, the looting of natural resources, the exploitation of labor, the insults and humiliations that countries that are not America or itıs chosen friends have to endure in the face of taunting arrogance of the superiority of American democracy, freedom, morality, wealth and intelligence. And, in deed, there is great wealth except those who are not so fortunate to share in itıs distribution and there are clever people who have made clever discoveries and devices; that cannot be disputed.

 

There is also this 'kind of' democracy and freedom to be ignored and assumption that the FBI wonıt come calling -- you can carry your placard, write letters to the editor, sign petitions -- all for nothing. And what of this American morality, this American compassion -- I donıt see it in the bombing, in the amassing of wealth at the expense of the disadvantaged, in the suffering around the world, for the new found interest in the liberation of women of Afghanistan. I guess that is what it is that is so infuriating: the sham, the fraud -- the country is full of hatred, violence and madness -- watch television or read your daily newspaper if you donıt think so. And I guess that only adds to the anger: Americans will watch television or read their newspapers and magazines and see greatness and goodness while I see deception, misery, insanity, viciousness. Am I the only one.

 

And letıs talk about culture, the culture of America. The mass culture, the culture that is enjoyed by the overwhelming numbers of Americans is of the worst degraded quality imaginable. In popular music, art (television and movies), cuisine, style, literature we find the trashiest, lowest and most depraved being the most popular. So this is what we have: the fantasy of the superiority of America against the reality of miserable America and the fantasy of the goodness of America against the reality of an aggressive, brutal, murderous America. Is it no wonder the country is awash in mind numbing drugs of the illegal and legal variety? Is it possible that a country can look into the vacuous face of George W. Bush and see greatness and goodness. What kind of a country kills thousands in Afghanistan but admits to nothing, that looks the other way.

 

 

 

What kind of a country takes advantage of a national tragedy to take away citizenıs rights, give more money to the rich, spread fear throughout the land and at the same time engage in the most boastful and self satisfied rhetoric. Thatıs what I see: lies, hatred, savagery, stupidity -- maybe that is what some other people also see but apparently they donıt live in America.

 

**********************************************************

* Lee Roskin mailto:ledros@got.net *

* Techno Light & Sound http://www.got.net/~krish *

**********************************************************